This paper provides a broad discussion of the security issues related to virtualization technology, such as the offerings by VMware, Microsoft and IBM. It presents an overview of virtualization, the various types of virtualization, and a detailed discussion of full computer virtualization technology. The benefits of virtualization technology are provided from a position of security, convenience and cost. The paper continues with a discussion of the security liabilities of virtualization. It provides examples of recent attempts by security researchers to design attacks directed at the virtual machine manager also known as the hypervisor. A look at trends in the application of virtualization technology concludes the discussion.Virtualization is a type of abstraction of resources. In computer technology, virtualization can be used to simulate the presence of memory, disk, video or entire computers where they exist partially or not at all. The first virtualization technology dates back into 1960, when IBM and other computing pioneers created operating systems and storage systems that presented an isolated environment to the user that appeared as a single-user system. Today our desktop operating systems use memory virtualization to provide a larger runtime space for applications than there is random access memory. Our operating system uses a combination of solid-state memory and a paging file on disk to move data blocks between to two media depending on their frequency of use. Enterprise storage virtualization, such as solutions provided by IBM, EMC and Sun create an illusion of massive consolidated storage space available from solid-state, magnetic disk and streaming tape into a single logical direct access image. Less frequently accessed data blocks are migrated to slower media while often-accessed data blocks are maintained on faster access media. All storage appears online and ready to access. The recent the popularity of virtual machines for running Java and .NET software allow a common runtime environment regardless of the actual hardware and operating system hosting the virtual machine. This approach reduces the work required by the software provider to create a solution capable of running on a variety of platforms.Cardwell (2007) defines computer virtualization as a computer within a computer. Virtualization software simulates a computer, including the processor and hardware components, and BIOS to the guest operating system. The guest operating system running within the virtualized environment should not know or care that its hardware resources are not physical resources, but instead simulated through software. The two types of computer virtualization are called full virtualization and para-virtualization. Wong (2005) discusses the differences of full virtualization and para-virtualization. Full virtualization does not require changes to the guest operating system. Products such as VMware provide full virtualization. This type of virtualization requires support in the host system’s processor to trap and help emulate privileged instructions executed by the guest operating system. Para-virtualization requires modifications to the guest OS to run on the virtual machine manager. Open source operating systems, such as Linux can be modified to support a para-virtualized environment. This type of virtualization often performs better than full virtualization, but is restricted to guest operating systems that have been modified to run in this specific environment.Today there are many popular, contemporary and affordable virtualization products on the market. VMware is the most widely known, but IBM has the longest history with virtualization technologies. As mentioned previously, virtualization for mainframe systems dates back to 1960. VMware has targeted Intel platform virtualization since the 1990s. Microsoft acquired Virtual PC as the market for virtualization grew from VMware’s popularity. Xen is an open source virtualization solution. Xen supports full and para-virtualized systems. It is popular with Linux distributions, which often provide para-virtualized kernels ready to deploy as guest operating systems. IBM’s two primary virtualization platforms are the System-z mainframe and Power systems. “The latest version of z/VM […] will now support up to 32 processors and offer users 128 GB of memory, which will allow the software to host more than 1,000 virtual […] Linux servers.” (Ferguson, 2007).Virtualization technology, which was originally used on centralized systems to share resources and provide a partitioned view to a single user, is popular on server and workstation platforms running Intel x86 hardware. Cardwell (2007) presents several use cases of virtualization benefits, including consolidation of servers, quick enterprise solutions, software development, and sales demonstrations. Separate physical servers running periodically accessed services can be virtualized and run together on a single physical system. Short-lived server systems, such as those for conferences, could be created as virtual machines without the need for acquiring physical servers to host the solution. Software developers often need multiple systems to develop server-based solutions, or they require several versions tools that may conflict when installed together. Sales demonstrations can be configured and distributed to customer-facing staff as virtual machines. Many different configurations can be created and options demonstrated to customers on demand to see how various solutions can apply to their environment. As processing capability increases on the desktop and virtualization providers offer cost-effective software to create virtualized environments, this is a primary growth area for the technology. Burt (2006) says the benefit of mobility of virtual machines for users is a huge benefit of desktop virtualization. Virtual machines stored on portable media such as USB hard disks or flash storage. They can be paused on a host system at an office, taken on plane to the customer’s location and then resumed on a new host. This can happen while keeping the virtualized operating system completely oblivious to its actual location and host hardware. Testing and quality assurance has had large adoption of virtualization technology. According to Tiller (2006), the benefits of virtualization include the ability to react and test vulnerabilities and patches in a much shorter timeframe. Single virtualized systems can be dedicated to an individual task in a network of systems. Upgrading or relocating any virtualized system can be performed without affecting other parts of the entire solution.There is a large benefit to security and availability with virtualization technology. Virtual machines are separated from the host operating system. Viruses, malware and software defects that affect the virtualized system are restricted and, in most cases cannot spread to the host operating system. Disaster recovery planning has the potential for simplification under a virtualized infrastructure. Virtual machines images, such as those used by VMware, are stored on the host operating system as files. Backing-up or relocating virtual machines from one host to another can be as simple as suspending the running virtual machine, moving the set of files across the network and resuming the virtual machine. Virtual machine images can be shortly suspended and stored to tape or mirrored to a remote location as a disaster recovery process. Duntemann (2005) points out that a virtual machine with the operating system and installed applications are commonly stored as disk files and can be archived, distributed, or restored to an initial state using the virtual machine manager. These files are also subject to attack and potential modification if the host system is compromised. A successful attack against the host system can make the virtual machines vulnerable to modification or other penetration.Virtualization is also known as a system multiplier technology. “It is very likely that IT managers will have to increase the number and expertise of security personnel devoted to security policy creation and maintenance as the percentage of VMs increase in the data center.” (Sturdevant, 2008). Where a virus would previously attack a single operating system running on a physical host, a virus can land on the host or any of its virtualized guests. The potential of creating an army of infected systems is possible now with just a single physical host. A Windows operating system running in a virtual machine is just as vulnerable to flaws and exploits as the same operating system running on a physical host. “At a broad level, virtualized environments require the same physical and network security precautions as any non-virtualized IT resource.” (Peterson, 2007). “[…] because of the rush to adopt virtualization for server consolidation, many security issues are overlooked and best practices are not applied.” There are fundamental problems for IT administrators adopting virtualization technology within their labs and data centers. Products such as VMware have internal virtual networks that exist only within the host system. This network allows the virtualized systems and the host to communicate without having the use the external, physical network. The difficulty is that monitoring the internal, virtual network requires the installation of tools that are designed for virtualized systems. Edwards (2009) points out the need for management tools to monitor communication among virtual machines and their host operating system in detail. Each host would require monitoring tools versus a single installation on a network of only physical systems. Discovery and management of virtualized systems will place more burdens on IT staff according to Tiller (2006). The ease with which virtual machines can be instantiated, relocated and destroyed will require a “quantum shift in security strategy and willingness to adapt.“As the popularity of virtualization on a smaller scale has increased, a new class of attack on virtual machines and their host virtual machine managers has received more attention. Virtual machines have unique hardware signatures that can be used to identify them and help an attacker tailor an exploit. “As it is, virtualization vendors have some work to do to protect virtual machine instances from being discovered as virtual.” (Yager, 2006). The CPU model and various device drivers loaded by the operating system can identify a virtualized system. In fact, many virtualization vendors supply device drivers for guest operating systems to take better advantage of the virtualized environment. These device drivers are just as susceptible to flaws and vulnerabilities as their non-virtualized counterparts are. The host virtual machine managers, also known as hypervisors are being targeted as well by new types of attacks. Vijayan (2007) points out that dedicated hypervisors, running directly above the hardware of a computer can be used to attack the operating systems and applications it hosts with little or no possibility of detection. The SubVirt research project by University of Michigan and Microsoft uses virtual machine technology to install a rootkit to take control of multiple virtual machines. Finally, attacks using virtualization technology does not require hypervisor or virtual machine manager software at all. Technology present in today microprocessors that is utilized by hypervisors can also be utilized by malware, such as rootkits and viruses to take over a machine at the lowest level of control possible. “Security researcher Joanna Rutkowska presented a proof of concept attack known as ‘blue pill’ in 2006, that she said virtualized an operating system and was undetectable. […] Rutkowska and other have continued with such research, and this year she posited a new attack focusing on hypervisors.” (Bradbury, 2008).Virtualization is not a new to information technology. It dates back to over four decades to the early mainframes and large storage systems to protect and better utilize available computing resources. As this paper discussed virtualization technology, it detailed the kinds, benefits and security liabilities of the technology. Information about the nature of attacks against hosts and guests in a virtualized infrastructure was presented. New virtualization products for modern powerful servers and desktop hardware are helping satisfy the renewed interest in making better use of resources during tightening budgets. The benefits of this updated technology must be weighed against the challenges of securing and protecting the proliferation of virtual machines. Adaptation and transformation of policies and approach within IT organizations must be proactive to stay ahead of the disruptive change currently taking place with virtualization.ReferencesBradbury, D. (2008). Virtually secure? Engineering & Technology. 8 November - 21 November, 2008. Pg. 54.Burt, J., Spooner, J. G. (2006). Virtualization edges toward PCs. eWeek. February 20, 2006. Pg. 24.Cardwell, T. (2007). Virtualization: an overview of the hottest technology that is changing the way we use computers. November/December, 2007. Pg. 26.Duntemann, J. (2005). Inside the virtual machine. PC Magazine. September 20, 2005. Pg. 66.Edwards, J. (2009). Securing your virtualized environment. Computerworld. March 16, 2009. Pg. 26.Ferguson, S. (2007). IBM launches new virtualization tools. eWeek. February 12/19, 2007. Pg. 18.Peterson, J. (2007). Security rules have changed. Communications News. May, 2007. Pg. 18.PowerVM. (2009). IBM PowerVM: The virtualization platform for UNIX, Linux and IBM i clients. Retrieved July 25, 2009 from, C. (2008). Security in a virtualized world. eWeek. September 22, 2008. Pg. 35.Tiller, J. (2006). Virtual security: the new security tool? Information Systems Security. July/August, 2006. Pg. 2.Wong, W. (2005). Platforms strive for virtual security. Electronic Design. August 4, 2005. Pg. 44.Yager, T. (2006). Virtualization and security. Infoworld. November 20, 2006. Pg. 16.Vijayan, J. (2007). Virtualization increases IT security pressures. Computerworld. August 27, 2007. Pg. 14.